Industries Most Commonly Audited in New York
Workers’ comp audits are common across industries, but insurers focus heavily on high-risk sectors.
1. Construction
Construction has:
- High injury risk
- Frequent subcontractors
- Misclassification issues
Common problems:
- 1099 workers treated as contractors
- Missing subcontractor insurance certificates
- Payroll underreporting
2. Restaurants and Hospitality
Restaurants often face audits because of:
- High employee turnover
- Cash payroll
- Overtime issues
Auditors often review:
- Kitchen staff payroll
- Delivery drivers
- Overtime payments
3. Cleaning Services
4
Cleaning businesses frequently have:
- Contract labor
- Misclassified workers
- Cash payments
Many insurers assume contract cleaners are employees unless proven otherwise.
4. Landscaping and Tree Services
4
These businesses have:
- Seasonal workers
- High injury risk
- Subcontract labor
Workers’ comp rates are higher due to equipment risk.
How Tax Professionals Can Charge for Workers’ Comp Audit Help
Helping clients respond to audits is a high-value advisory service.
Typical pricing ranges:
| Service | Typical Fee |
|---|---|
| Audit preparation | $500 – $1,500 |
| Audit representation | $1,500 – $3,000 |
| Complex construction audit | $3,000 – $5,000+ |
Services you can offer:
✔ Payroll reconciliation
✔ Worker classification review
✔ Documentation preparation
✔ Communication with auditor
✔ Dispute assistance
Many business owners panic when they receive an audit letter — which makes this an excellent advisory opportunity.
Tax Professional Strategy: Turn Audits Into Advisory Clients
Smart firms use audits to build long-term advisory relationships.
Offer:
- Payroll compliance reviews
- Worker classification consulting
- Risk management planning
- Payroll restructuring
This can lead to ongoing monthly advisory services.
Red Flags That Trigger Workers’ Comp Audits
Insurers often audit when they see:
- Payroll spikes
- Large contractor payments
- Industry risk (construction, roofing)
- Inconsistent payroll filings
- Claims filed during policy period
Example Audit Scenario
A New York construction company estimated payroll at $500,000.
During the audit, the insurer found:
- $300,000 paid to subcontractors without insurance
- $100,000 unreported payroll
Final payroll used for the premium:
$900,000
Result:
Large premium increase.
Advice for Business Owners
Businesses should keep audit-ready records year-round.
Best practices:
✔ Track payroll by employee classification
✔ Maintain subcontractor insurance certificates
✔ Keep payroll and accounting records organized
✔ Review workers’ comp policy classifications annually
Responses