Timing Strategies That Save Money

For tax professionals, one of the most common strategic questions from business clients is:

“Should I incorporate now, or should I wait?”

The answer is rarely simple. Timing an entity change — whether forming an LLC, electing S Corporation status, or converting from sole proprietor to corporation — can significantly impact taxes, compliance costs, and long-term planning.

This article breaks down the strategic factors tax advisors should evaluate before recommending incorporation.

---

1. Understand the Client’s Current Tax Exposure

Before discussing entity structure, analyze:

• Net profit (not gross revenue)
• Self-employment tax exposure
• Marginal tax bracket
• State tax impact
• Existing liabilities and contracts

For many sole proprietors filing Schedule C, the biggest driver of incorporation timing is self-employment tax savings.

Key Rule of Thumb

If consistent net profit exceeds approximately $40,000–$60,000, it may be time to evaluate S Corporation treatment.

But timing matters.

---

2. The Mid-Year Incorporation Trap

Many clients decide to incorporate in the middle of the year after realizing profits are higher than expected.

This creates issues:

• Partial-year Schedule C + partial-year S Corp
• Payroll setup midstream
• Potential late S-election problems
• Complicated bookkeeping allocations
• Split depreciation schedules

Strategic Insight

If incorporation is likely, early-year formation (January 1 effective date) simplifies:

• Payroll planning
• Accountable plans
• Health insurance strategy
• Retirement contributions

Late-year elections may limit tax optimization opportunities.

---

3. S Corporation Timing Strategies

When electing S Corporation status, timing is critical.

To Be Effective for Current Year:

• Form entity and file Form 2553 within 2 months and 15 days of formation
  OR
• File late election relief under Rev. Proc. 2013-30

However, even when late election relief is available, the administrative burden increases.

Strategic Advantage of Early Election:

• Clean payroll setup
• Defined reasonable compensation planning
• Maximized SE tax savings
• Coordinated retirement planning (Solo 401(k), SEP, etc.)

---

4. When Waiting Makes More Sense

Incorporation is not always immediately beneficial.

Consider waiting if:

• Profit is inconsistent or seasonal
• Net income is under $30,000
• Client lacks proper bookkeeping
• Administrative capacity is weak
• Client is still validating the business model

Incorporating too early can:

• Increase compliance costs
• Trigger unnecessary payroll expenses
• Create additional state filing fees
• Reduce flexibility

For low-profit startups, staying Schedule C temporarily may be more efficient.

---

5. State-Level Timing Considerations

State franchise taxes and annual minimum taxes can affect timing decisions.

Examples to analyze:

• Annual franchise tax due upon formation
• Registered agent fees
• State payroll registration
• Workers’ compensation requirements

Forming in December may trigger full-year state fees for minimal benefit.

Sometimes waiting until January 1 avoids paying two years of state minimum taxes within weeks.

---

6. Liability Exposure vs. Tax Savings

Some clients need incorporation immediately for legal protection, not tax reasons.

High-risk industries:

• Construction
• Real estate development
• Consulting with contractual exposure
• Businesses with employees

In these cases, legal risk may outweigh tax timing strategy.

As advisors, coordinate with legal counsel when liability protection is urgent.

---

7. Asset Protection & Business Credit Timing

Incorporating earlier may help clients:

• Establish business credit history
• Separate personal and business finances
• Secure contracts requiring entity structure
• Improve vendor relationships

Waiting could delay financing opportunities.

---

8. Retirement & Benefit Planning Windows

Entity choice impacts:

• Solo 401(k) calculations
• SEP contribution limits
• Defined benefit plans
• Health insurance deductibility

S Corporations require wages to calculate retirement contributions properly.

Late incorporation can restrict retirement maximization strategies.

---

9. Conversion Planning: Built-In Gain & Basis Issues

If converting an existing business:

• Review asset basis
• Analyze depreciation recapture
• Consider built-in gain exposure (if converting to C Corp)
• Evaluate shareholder basis planning

Timing affects tax consequences.

---

10. A Strategic Framework for Advisors

When advising clients, evaluate five pillars:

1. Profit Level

Is SE tax savings meaningful?

2. Administrative Capacity

Can they handle payroll and compliance?

3. State Cost Analysis

Does timing increase franchise tax exposure?

4. Long-Term Vision

Growth, investors, employees?

5. Risk Profile

Is liability exposure high?

---

Practical Timing Scenarios

Scenario A: Growing Consultant (March, $25K YTD Profit)

Recommendation: Form LLC now, elect S Corp effective January 1 next year unless profit projects $80K+.

Scenario B: Real Estate Agent (July, $90K YTD Net)

Recommendation: Evaluate immediate S election with late relief to reduce SE tax.

Scenario C: Startup with $15K Profit

Recommendation: Stay Schedule C, focus on growth and bookkeeping discipline.

---

Final Strategic Takeaway

Incorporation is not just a structural decision — it is a timing strategy.

The wrong timing can:

• Reduce tax savings
• Increase compliance cost
• Create administrative complexity

The right timing can:

• Save thousands in self-employment taxes
• Improve retirement contributions
• Enhance liability protection
• Position the business for growth

As tax professionals, our role is not simply forming entities — it is designing the optimal timeline for financial efficiency.

Smart incorporation isn’t about “now or later.”
It’s about when it creates measurable value.