🧾 1. NY FAIR PLAY ACT

Client Risk Assessment Checklist

Use this during onboarding or before issuing any Form 1099-NEC.

🔍 Worker Classification Review

Ask your client:

Behavioral Control

  • ☐ Do you set the worker’s schedule?
  • ☐ Do you supervise or direct how the work is performed?
  • ☐ Do you require the worker to follow company procedures?
  • ☐ Do you provide training?

Financial Control

  • ☐ Do you provide tools or equipment?
  • ☐ Do you purchase materials?
  • ☐ Do you reimburse expenses?
  • ☐ Do you pay hourly or weekly?
  • ☐ Is this their primary source of income?

Relationship of the Parties

  • ☐ Is the work performed part of your core service?

Examples:

Company TypeWorker Role
Roofing CompanyRoofer
Framing CompanyFramer
Painting CompanyPainter
Electrical ContractorElectrician

🚨 If YES → Likely Employee under NY Fair Play Act


Independence Test

  • ☐ Does the worker advertise their services?
  • ☐ Do they work for other companies?
  • ☐ Do they have business insurance?
  • ☐ Do they operate under a separate business name?
  • ☐ Do they have their own tools?

📌 Risk Determination

ScoreRisk Level
0–3 YESLow Risk
4–6 YESModerate Risk
7+ YES🚨 HIGH RISK

⚖️ 2. 1099 vs W-2 Decision Tree (Construction Industry)

Step 1:

Is the worker performing work that is part of the company’s normal construction activity?

➡️ YES → Go to Step 2
➡️ NO → Possibly Independent Contractor


Step 2:

Does the company:

  • Set the schedule?
  • Supervise the work?
  • Provide tools or materials?

➡️ YES to ANY → 🚨 Must be W-2 Employee under NY Fair Play Act

➡️ NO to ALL → Go to Step 3


Step 3:

Does the worker:

  • Maintain a separate business location?
  • Work for multiple companies?
  • Advertise services publicly?
  • Carry their own insurance?

➡️ YES to ALL → May qualify as Independent Contractor
➡️ NO to ANY → 🚨 Must be W-2


🛡️ 3. Misclassification Audit Defense Intake Form

Use this if client already issued 1099s and is being audited.


Company Information

  • Legal Business Name:
  • EIN:
  • Industry:
  • Years in Business:

Worker Information

  • Worker Name:
  • LLC or Sole Proprietor?
  • EIN or SSN:
  • Start Date:
  • End Date:

Work Arrangement

  • ☐ Written Contract Exists
  • ☐ Worker Sets Own Schedule
  • ☐ Worker Supplies Tools
  • ☐ Worker Purchases Materials
  • ☐ Worker Can Hire Assistants
  • ☐ Worker Works for Other Companies
  • ☐ Worker Has Liability Insurance
  • ☐ Worker Advertises Services
  • ☐ Worker Has Business Website

Payment Structure

  • ☐ Paid by the job
  • ☐ Paid hourly
  • ☐ Paid weekly
  • ☐ Paid upon project completion

Control Factors

  • ☐ Company supervised work
  • ☐ Company provided training
  • ☐ Company required uniform
  • ☐ Company dictated work method
  • ☐ Worker required to report daily

Documentation Available

  • ☐ Invoices
  • ☐ Proof of Insurance
  • ☐ Business Registration
  • ☐ Marketing Materials
  • ☐ Equipment Ownership Proof

Need Help?

We’ve partnered with SilverLine Insurance to help make Workers Comp easy. Give them a call today –> 718-499-0700.

Related Articles

Responses